No Pay Gap For Female Zoo Vets, but Children Perceived as Career Hindrance
For Immediate Release
For female veterinarians who want to specialize in zoological work, a new study on family work and income for diplomates of the American College of Zoological Medicine (ACZM) holds both good and bad news. While women in the field don’t seem to suffer from a gender pay gap, many feel that they must give up on having children in order to succeed.
Becoming an ACZM diplomate is an arduous process. Candidates have two paths to the achievement: either internship and residency at a zoo for four to six years after finishing a doctorate of veterinary medicine, or full-time work in a zoo for six years. Both paths require the applicant to publish three to five research papers in the field and pass a two-day exam.
“There aren’t a lot of ACZM diplomates in the world – fewer than 300 – but there aren’t that many zoos, either, so it is a very competitive field,” says Tara Harrison, associate professor of zoological medicine at North Carolina State University and lead author of the study.
Harrison sent a 127-item online survey to 201 ACZM diplomates (106 females and 95 males) classified as active members in 2018. Responses were anonymous. The survey contained questions regarding career type, job title, annual income, benefits, gender, race and ethnicity, job location, whether respondents had children, whether respondents had chosen to delay having children, whether having children had affected respondents’ career, and whether respondents felt that gender had affected their career.
“We did this first of all because of the perception that diplomates are highly trained, but that their salaries don’t compare with those of other specialties,” Harrison says. “Samantha Morello, associate professor at the Cornell Center for Veterinary Business and Entrepreneurship, had done a similar study in veterinarians, so we partnered to repeat the study on this population.”
The study found that compared to other veterinary specialists – who make an average of $130,000 per year – ACZM diplomates did make less, with a mean salary of $105,000 per year (higher for those in academia and lower for those working in zoos and aquariums). There were no differences in incomes between male and female respondents when they were matched for gender and age. Additionally, there were no significant differences in income between males and females with or without children.
But when it came to having a family, respondents’ perception of its effect on career did differ by gender. Seventy-six percent of females and 47% of males reported delaying having children because of their career. Additionally, 65% of females with children felt that having children had a negative effect on their career, compared to 16% of males with children. Finally, 85% of females without children, and 44% of males without children, thought having children would have negatively affected their careers.
“It is startling how many women thought kids would have an effect or felt that they did have an effect on career,” Harrison says. “Perhaps this is due to the competitive nature of the field – the respondents believe availability and the ability to move to where the jobs are can be affected by having children.
“I hope that diplomates – particularly women, since this concept affects them disproportionately – aren’t feeling pressure not to have families because they feel they can’t have one and do the career properly,” Harrison says.
The research appears in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association.
Note to editors: An abstract follows.
“Effects of gender on income and family planning for diplomates of the American College of Zoological Medicine”
Authors: Tara Harrison, Kenneth Royal, Olivia Petritz, Amy Snyder, North Carolina State University; Samantha Morello, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Published: Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association
To evaluate income and family planning decisions of American College of Zoological Medicine (ACZM) diplomates.
98 ACZM diplomates.
An online survey was sent to 201 ACZM diplomates. Participation was voluntary.
98 (49%) diplomates responded to the survey. The most commonly reported income categories were $90,000 to $94,999, $100,000 to $104,999, and $110,000 to $114,999. Overall, the mean of the salary-category midpoint responses was $105,357 but was $122,917 for those in academia and $94,508 for those working in zoos and aquaria. When incomes of males and females were matched (24 pairs matched for gender and age), no difference in income was observed. There were no significant differences in income between males and females with and without children.
Diplomates who did not complete a residency had significantly higher incomes than diplomates who did. Sixteen of 21 (76%) females and 9 of 19 (47%) males reported delaying having children because of their career. Additionally, a higher percentage of females with children (13/20 [65%]) than males with children (3/19 [16%]) felt that having children had had a negative effect on their career. Thirty-five of 41 (85%) females without children and 4 of 9 (44%) males without children thought having children would have negatively affected their careers.
Although substantial differences in income between female and male ACZM diplomates were not identified, differences in family planning and perceptions of the impact of having children on their careers did exist.