New Technique Helps Probe Performance of Organic Solar Cell Materials

A research team led by North Carolina State University has developed a new technique for determining the role that a material’s structure has on the efficiency of organic solar cells, which are candidates for low-cost, next generation solar power. The researchers have used the technique to determine that materials with a highly organized structure at the nanoscale are not more efficient at creating free electrons than poorly organized structures – a finding which will help guide future research and development efforts.

“There have been a lot of studies looking at the efficiency of organic solar cells, but the energy conversion process involves multiple steps – and it’s difficult to isolate the efficiency of each step,” says Dr. Brendan O’Connor, an assistant professor of mechanical engineering at NC State and senior author of a paper on the subject. “The technique we discuss in our new paper allows us to untangle those variables and focus on one specific step – exciton dissociation efficiency.”

Broadly speaking, organic solar cells convert light into electric current in four steps.

First, the cell absorbs sunlight, which excites electrons in the active layer of the cell. Each excited electron leaves behind a hole in the active layer. The electron and hole are collectively called an exciton. In the second step, called diffusion, the exciton hops around until it encounters an interface with another organic material in the active layer. When the exciton meets this interface, you get step three: dissociation. During dissociation, the exciton breaks apart, freeing the electron and respective hole. In step four, called charge collection, the free electron makes its way through the active layer to a point where it can be harvested.

In previous organic solar cell research, there was ambiguity about whether differences in efficiency were due to dissociation or charge collection – because there was no clear method for distinguishing between the two within a single film. Was a material inefficient at dissociating excitons into free electrons? Or was the material just making it hard for free electrons to find their way out?

To address these questions, the researchers developed a method that takes advantage of a particular characteristic of light: if light is polarized so that it “runs” parallel to the long axis of organic solar cell molecules, it will be absorbed; but if the light runs perpendicular to the molecules, it passes right through it.

The researchers created highly organized nanostructures within a portion of the active layer of an organic solar cell, meaning that the molecules in that portion all ran the same way. They left the remaining regions of the cell disorganized, meaning the molecules ran in a bunch of different directions. This design allowed the researchers to make the organized areas of the cell effectively invisible by controlling the polarity of light aimed at the active layer. In other words, the researchers could test just the organized section or just the disorganized section – even though they were in the same active layer of the same solar cell.

Because the charge collection would be the same for both regions (since they were on the same active layer), the technique allowed the researchers to measure the degree to which structural organization affected the material’s dissociation efficiency.

“We found that there was no relationship between dissociation efficiency and structural organization,” O’Connor says. “It was really a surprise, and it tells us that we don’t need highly ordered nanostructures for efficient free electron generation.

“In practical terms, this technique will help distinguish efficiency losses of newly developed materials, helping define which material and nanostructure features are needed to advance organic solar cell technology.”

The paper, “In-Plane Alignment in Organic Solar Cells to Probe the Morphological Dependence of Charge Recombination,” was published online Jan. 21 in the journal Advanced Functional Materials. Lead author of the paper is Omar Awartani, a Ph.D. student at NC State. Co-authors include Dr. Michael Kudenov of NC State and Dr. Joseph Kline of the National Institute of Standards and Technology. The work was funded by the National Science Foundation under grant number 1200340.

-shipman-

Note to Editors: The study abstract follows.

“In-Plane Alignment in Organic Solar Cells to Probe the Morphological Dependence of Charge Recombination”

Authors: Omar Awartani, Michael W. Kudenov, and Brendan T. O’Connor, North Carolina State University; R. Joseph Kline, National Institute of Standards and Technology

Published: online Jan. 21, Advanced Functional Materials

DOI: 10.1002/adfm.201403377

Abstract: Bulk heterojunction (BHJ) organic solar cells are fabricated with the polymer semiconductor aligned in the plane of the film to probe charge recombination losses associated with aggregates characterized by varying degrees of local order. 100% uniaxial strain is applied on ductile poly(3-hexylthiophene):phenyl-C61-butyric acid methyl ester (P3HT:PCBM) BHJ films and characterize the resulting morphology with ultraviolet-visible absorption spectroscopy and grazing incidence X-ray diffraction. It is found that the strained films result in strong alignment of the highly ordered polymer aggregates. Polymer aggregates with lower order and amorphous regions also align but with a much broader orientation distribution. The solar cells are then tested under linearly polarized light where the light is selectively absorbed by the appropriately oriented polymer, while maintaining a common local environment for the sweep out of photogenerated charge carriers. Results show that charge collection losses associated with a disordered BHJ film are circumvented, and the internal quantum efficiency is independent of P3HT local aggregate order near the heterojunction interface. Uniquely, this experimental approach allows for selective excitation of distinct morphological features of a conjugated polymer within a single BHJ film, providing insight into the morphological origin of recombination losses.