Skip to main content

Trash May Be (Energy) Treasure Trove

Could this be the future of energy in the U.S.?

Earlier this month, a New York Times article highlighted the fact that European countries are burning garbage as a renewable source of energy – but that similar efforts in the United States are lagging behind. The article cites a 2009 study which “came down strongly in favor of waste-to-energy (WTE) plants over landfills as the most environmentally friendly destination for urban waste that cannot be recycled.” I was curious about the research itself, and set out to learn a little more about it.

The study, “Is It Better To Burn or Bury Waste for Clean Electricity Generation?,” was published in 2009 by Environmental Science & Technology, and was co-authored by NC State University’s Dr. Joe DeCarolis, with Ozge Kaplan and Susan Thorneloe from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

The researchers had set out to determine the potential greenhouse gas impact of two alternative energy sources: WTE and landfill-gas-to-energy (LFGTE). WTE is when municipal solid waste (i.e., garbage) is incinerated to create electricity. LFGTE is when you dump garbage in a landfill, wait for it to produce methane, and then use that methane to create electricity.

“The bottom line is that the study indicates WTE produces significantly less greenhouse gas than LFGTE, and appears to compare favorably to coal,” says DeCarolis. (I would also observe that we’re making lots of garbage every day, and the supply of easily accessible coal is not infinite – but the research doesn’t go into that.)

Stay tuned for future developments in this area. DeCarolis is working with NC State’s Dr. Morton Barlaz to analyze additional data on carbon sequestration at landfills. Their findings may affect current calculations on the attractiveness of LFGTE as an option for addressing greenhouse gas concerns.

Leave a Response

Your email address will not be published. All fields are required.

  1. Our company, Waste To Energy International, represents a major technology provider in Europe who has been building WTE plants in Europe, Russia and other parts of the world for many years and has clearly demonstrated data from production plants that this form of energy production is clean and efficient … and renewable (as long as humans produce waste).
    Incidently, WTE is not just limited to solid waste but also (liquid) sludge. WTE International has special technology to produce energy from all forms of waste , including sludge.

    USA is ready for this, but needs more political will to make it happen faster.

  2. I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

  3. Hi there, You craft some quality blogs, I really like nearly all of your current articles. I always check back here often to find out in case you have modified. Carry on blogging!